What Do News Execs of Color Owe Their Communities?
Sunday, November 4, 2012
Romney Losing in State Where He Was Governor
Romney Charging Journalists to Enter Campaign HQ
64% of Latinos for Obama, 8% Lean Toward Him in Poll
N.Y. Post Demands That Christie Praise Romney
Sudanese Journalist Found Tortured, Head Shaved
President Obama is expected to receive upwards of 90 percent of the African American vote in Tuesday's election, despite a phenomenon not unknown to other people of color in executive positions, even in the news business: muted disappointment by some that he has not done enough for his own.
The latest writer to make this point is Gary Younge, the black British U.S. correspondent for the Guardian newspaper, who in analyzing "Barack Obama and the paradox behind his black support base," included this line Saturday: ". . . the ascent of America's first black president has coincided with the one of the steepest descents of the economic fortunes of black Americans since the second world war both in real terms and relative to whites."
Becoming the first person of color in an executive position in a mainstream institution brings expectations — and fears — that the new executive will be more sensitive to one's own ethnic group, the way others have been to theirs. Sometimes that's true, sometimes not. Some African Americans complain that their African American bosses have gone out of their way to "be mean" to them, as one journalist said. But as the late Gerald R. Boyd, the first African American managing editor of the New York Times, discovered, the stance taken is no protection from charges of favoritism.
After the Jayson Blair plagiarism scandal of 2003, Boyd told the in-house Siegal Committee investigating the Blair scandal: ". . . I incurred some criticism from journalists of color who felt I was not looking out for them. My view was that it was competitive and a matter of merit." Yet Boyd was portrayed in the news media as Blair's protector and mentor. Both were black.
As with the president, community members also have expectations. Their efforts resulted in the desegregation of newsrooms.
Six people of color with ties to the news business responded by email Monday to a request to discuss these aspects of leadership. Most were members of the now-defunct National Association of Minority Media Executives (NAMME), later National Association of Multicultural Media Executives.
Ronald B. Brown, president, Banks Brown, consultant to journalist of color organizations:
. . . As more black people ascend to CEO and heads of major institutions, their priorities dramatically expand. They are compelled to focus on the broader health of the enterprise. Most of these people have been able to place trusted surrogates in valued positions and address specific black issues within the context of overall goals, i.e. lifting the middle class (very important to the African American community and its institutions. ref: Eugene Robinson's book ["Disintegration: The Splintering of Black America"]). Many blacks, without an understanding of the realities and limits of power, can become frustrated with this shift in focus.
The truth is that African Americans, throughout the first four years [of the Obama administration], have not asked for anything specific. Other groups, particularly the gay and lesbian community, have pressed their concerns, DADT ["Don't Ask, Don't Tell"], the Defense of Marriage Act, marriage, etc. On the whole, many African Americans seem content to bask in the glory of a Black President and defend him against vulnerability. On the other hand, there are some people who are willing to spend their efforts to judge, carp or criticize.
The symbolic and actual power of an African American president and first lady should stand as a high value standard that offers a U.S. and world platform for African Americans to make inroads, at all levels. Their visibility should be exploited as a competitive advantage. Under the banner of the Black leader of the free world, African Americans should be "running for daylight" to capture every edge we can create. We could be participating in the redevelopment of black neighborhoods with a focus on creating jobs or insinuating ourselves into ownership stakes in the public-private partnerships that will emerge in the next four years, thereby creating more jobs. If, after eight years with a African American president and first lady, African Americans are unable to build some important advantages, then we have to answer some critical questions. Was it him or us?
In truth. we are in a intense, competitive fight with other forces (i.e. tea party, etc.) for power to gain attention, focus and secure our interests. Our issues are broad and wide, all over the place and diffused. As a community, we lack a shared strategy (esp. an economic strategy) to gain our power objectives and collaborative leaders moving in 2-3 big priority directions.
Dinah Eng, founder, Executive Leadership Program, Asian American Journalists Association:
Yes, I believe it is true that people of color often criticize "their own" who are the first to lead organizations for not doing enough to help minorities. In the case of AAJA's Executive Leadership Program, there were certainly conversations around cultural perspective and how it impacts decision-making.
Since all conversations in the training program must remain confidential, I cannot comment on specific names and situations. In general, there were discussions around everything from "Editor A" uses being Asian to advance her own career, but doesn't help other Asians in the newsroom because she doesn't want the competition, to "Editor B" doesn't see himself as Asian and has not experienced the kind of racism others have because he's half-white, so he doesn't have the kind of commitment and passion needed to help others.
Neil Foote, final chairman, National Association of Multicultural Media Executives:
Our philosophy at NAMME was always to encourage our members to be the best possible leaders, but to acknowledge that sometimes race and gender may put them in situations where their leadership skills, acumen and potential might be questioned.
At the end of the day, NAMME's membership always represented members in key decision making [positions] at some of the largest media companies in the world (e.g. Gannett, NYTimes, AOL/Time Warner, McClatchy, CBS, Hearst, etc), which told me that these individuals were truly the best in the business — regardless of race — and that those companies chose these individuals because they were the best what they do.
For President Obama, he has had to deal with the "burden of race" whether he wanted to acknowledge it publicly or not. It's ironic that there are some pundits out there saying that there's a larger racial divide under his administration than ever in this country's history. Of course there is. The country's never had a Black president! With America becoming increasing diverse, then the notion of an African American — or soon enough a Hispanic — in the White House — will send chills up the spines of everybody. Yes, even Blacks, who want this person to only deliver for them. The President has delivered lots for Blacks in the country that may not be directly tangible. Sadly so, when he's out of office, those "intangibles" will become that much more real when there are few, if any, who may have diverse folks in their minds.
Wanda Lloyd, executive editor, Montgomery (Ala.) Advertiser:
We always walk a thin line between being top news executives and being people of color. I remember the discussions we had back in the '80s (Milton Coleman, I believe) about whether we are black first or journalists first. As a woman, I get the same question: Have I seen discrimination more as a woman or as a person of color?
As professionals, we must constantly explain to readers that we make decisions based on the value of news, based on facts and based on our many years of ethics training.
As for your question, yes, I have encountered cases where we've been accused by African Americans of negative, even racist coverage about black people and black issues. With older black readers, I fear that some of it may be a holdover from the days of the black press, where some black newspapers were indeed the conscience of the community and advocates for racial injustice.
I feel it is my responsibility as an editor — who happens to be African American — to be sure my entire staff thinks about balance and fairness. As the top editor, I've had to explain that to readers, either in phone calls or through columns. One example is how we portray local suspects in local violent crimes (most of whom, statistically, are African American). On the other hand, it is our responsibility to be sure people of color are used as expert sources in news stories or features to accurately portray our community as one that is diverse in all walks of life.
Karen Lincoln Michel, executive editor, Advertiser Media Network, Lafayette, La., and former president, Native American Journalists Association and Unity: Journalists of Color:
So far I haven't been called out for not doing enough for people of color. But then I've been executive editor for just seven months. Give it time.
When it comes to judging whether my newspaper accurately reflects communities of color, I am probably my harshest critic. I want our coverage to reflect the rich diversity in southern Louisiana and we are making strides in that area. We recently hired a food & culture editor who writes about Cajun and Creole influences in food, music and culture. And as much as this editor — who is African American and speaks Cajun French — has raised our features coverage to a new level, I want to see more throughout the entire newspaper.
I am a firm believer in building news staffs that reflect the community. When I started in March at The Daily Advertiser, there were two people of color in the newsroom (not including myself). Since then, I have hired seven people and promoted five. Of the new hires, four are African American, one is Asian American and one is of Native American descent. Of the promotions, one is African American and the other is a Latina. Although Cajuns aren't considered people of color, they definitely contribute to the area's cultural diversity. One of the staffers who was promoted is a Cajun female.
There are many stories The Daily Advertiser could be covering in local communities of color, and I have plans to pursue some of them in 2013. If people accused me now of not doing enough in terms of covering communities of color, I would have to agree. But I would also tell them about the plan I have to address it.
Virgil Smith, vice president/talent acquisition and diversity, Gannett Co., Inc., and former NAMME president:
I am not one who supports the concept that the President did not do much for African-Americans or other ethnic groups. Evaluate the policies he has put in place that benefited all Americans and especially those who received the payroll tax cuts. Look at the Dodd-Frank bill and saving the car industry, which has a large black population working in Detroit and other cities. Look at the Affordable Health Care Act and more. The U.S. population has benefited from these policies, which means they have benefited people of color.
When I was the first African-American publisher in North Carolina, specifically Asheville, there was great pride from blacks in the community and high expectations. Some of the expectations were filled by hiring a diverse workforce, putting in place policies that created a level playing field for how crime stories and photos of minorities were placed in the newspaper, including the daily lives of people of color in coverage, and ensuring that columnists espoused the views of minorities as well as the majority.
The point is, yes there are high expectations from people who look like you; however at the end of the day the President, editor, publisher, you name it, has the role to serve all of the people and that is what all of us [being queried] have done and it is what the President has done. He has appointed a diverse slate of people to his administration along with appointing the first Latina to the Supreme Court. Yes, he has lifted all of us in spirit, pride and with his deeds. He has given our children the dream that you can be President of the United States; his role will serve people for generations to come.
- Mark Russell, editor, Orlando Sentinel (Nov. 6)
|Comedian Chris Rock's "Message for White Voters," delivered on ABC's "The Jimmy Kimmel Show" Friday, went viral over the weekend. (Video)|
Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney is losing in his home state to President Obama, 42 percent to 57 percent, and Democrat Elizabeth Warren is leading Sen. Scott Brown, the Republican, by six percentage points, according to Public Policy Polling, a Democratic-leaning firm, Noah Bierman reported Saturday for the Boston Globe.
The Globe, the state's largest newspaper, has endorsed Obama.
"Somewhere in the Republican presidential nominee is the sensible, data-driven moderate that the Bay State knew as governor," the Globe's editorial board wrote last month, Matt Viser reported for boston.com.
"But it may also be that Massachusetts didn't know Mitt Romney very well, after all. Stuck in a party far to his right, Romney made a fateful bargain to adopt sharply conservative positions, and then start clawing back. Now, voters have no way of knowing what kind of president he'd be."
Viser pointed out that, "Since its first presidential endorsement – for Hubert Humphrey in 1968 – the Globe's editorial page has always supported the Democrat running for president. . . . Even when Romney was facing fellow Republicans, the Globe's editorial board opted against Romney. It backed John McCain in the 2008 Republican presidential primary, and Jon Huntsman during the 2012 Republican presidential primary."
"The campaign of Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney appears to be setting a precedent this election year in charging journalists and news organizations for any access to a presidential campaign headquarters on the night of the election," Robert Rizzuto reported Monday for the Republican in Springfield, Mass.
"Romney, the former Massachusetts governor who is locked in a tight race with Democratic President Barack Obama, will be holding his election night gathering at the Boston Convention and Exhibition Center, where access costs anywhere from $75 for a chair in the ballroom to $1,020 for permission to use the media filing center. Broadcast news organizations will be paying up to $6,500 for workspace.
"Obama's campaign party will be held at McCormick Place, in Chicago, and although his campaign is charging for premiums, credentialed reporters are granted access, which includes a workstation, electrical power and a wireless Internet connection, at no cost. . . . "
If the Latino vote is high, President Obama will carry the swing states of Nevada, Colorado, Virginia, and Florida, Latino Decisions, a Latino political opinion research firm, reported on Monday.
"impreMedia & Latino Decisions today released the last in a series of 11 weekly tracking polls with results suggesting President Obama is poised to win a record high share of the Latino vote, and in turn likely to win key swing states and enough electoral college votes to retain the presidency. . . .
"The President's support continued its steady climb with 64% saying they are certain to vote for him on election day and another 8% leaning towards him. Romney's supporters also remained consistent, but overall he was unable to make significant inroads with Latino voters. Week 11 polling found 22% said they were certain to or might vote for Romney, compared to 24% during Week 1 polling."
- Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders (AAPI) for Obama
- Charles Babington, Associated Press: Puerto Ricans are key in Florida Presidential vote
- Hugo Balta, NBCLatino: The road to the White House is through El Barrio
- David Bauder, Associated Press: Dizzying array of TV, media options available Election Night
- Nancy Benac, Associated Press: Hour by hour: What to watch on election night
- John Blake, CNN: Parallels to country's racist past haunt age of Obama
- Dana Davidsen, CNN: New York newspapers flip for Romney
- Bianca Davie, Associated Press: Does Obama Still Get Black Voters' Approval? (Video)
- Michael Eric Dyson with Wil LaVeist, "the Wil LaVeist Show," willaveist.com: Michael Eric Dyson on Obama (Audio)
- Charles D. Ellison, Uptown: Since When Did White Republicans Get So Black?
- Charles D. Ellison, Philadelphia Tribune: What Happens to Romney if GOP Loses?
- Jack Gillum and Luis Alonso Lugo, Associated Press: Latinos donating little to presidential races
- Don Gonyea, NPR: America's Changing Face Presents Challenges For The GOP
- Roy Greenslade, the Guardian, Britain: Newspaper endorsements swing in Romney's favour
- Rick Horowitz, YouTube: You Don't Count Unless You're Counted: Vote!
- Jeff Johnson with Wil LaVeist, "the Wil LaVeist Show," willaveist.com, Jeff Johnson on Blackmenvote.org (Audio)
- Howard Kurtz, Daily Beast: Much of the Media Is Calling the Presidential Race for Barack Obama
- David A. Love, the Grio: How will black America react to an Obama loss?
- Frank X. Moraga, Latina Lista: Control of the presidency, Congress will impact Latino community
- Native Americans for Obama
- The Obama Administration's Accomplishments for the African American Community
- Clarence Page, Chicago Tribune: Hidden side of Obama's race gap
- Jeremy W. Peters, New York Times: Dueling Bitterness on Cable News
- Pew Research Center: Obama Gains Edge in Campaign's Final Days
- Leonard Pitts Jr., Miami Herald: A lament after four years of no reconciliation
- President's accomplishments for Latino Americans
- Brian Stelter, New York Times: Facing an Election Night Clamor
- Stephen Stills, Rolling Stone: Stephen Stills on Mitt Romney: 'I Never Thought I'd See a Creepier Politician Than Nixon'
- Linda S. Wallace, Tri-State Defender, Memphis, Tenn.: A different type of conversation, starting on Nov. 7
- Edward Wasserman, Miami Herald: In praise of newspaper candidate endorsements
"In a remarkable lead editorial in Rupert Murdoch's New York Post today, the newspaper demands that New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie inject presidential politics into the cleanup effort under way in the wake of Hurricane Sandy," Eric Boehlert reported Sunday for Media Matters for America. "The Post insists he do so immediately or run the risk of being a labeled a traitor within the Republican Party.
"Murdoch's Post, at this very late state of the election run, demands Christie politicize the hurricane relief effort by basically campaigning for Mitt Romney in the context of the killer storm. (Christie hosted President Obama on Wednesday to survey the state's historic damage.) And if Christie does not, the Post warns, 'the Republican Party will never forgive him.' "
The Post said of Christie, ". . . true bipartisanship includes the need to make clear his belief that the incumbent's vigorous response to the disaster would have been more than matched by Mitt Romney had he been president."
- Emily Bell, the Guardian, Britain: From Storm Sandy to the election, speculation dominates the US media
- Hillel Italie, Associated Press: Sandy benefit concert pulls down $23 million in pledges
- Elizabeth Jensen, New York Times: Storm Poses First Major Test for NJTV News Coverage
- Louisa Ada Seltzer, Media Life Magazine: For ABC, a day of hurricane healing
"A critical Sudanese freelance journalist was found on the side of a road in Khartoum on Friday after being reported missing on October 29, according to news reports," the Committee to Protect Journalists reported on Monday. "Somaya Ibrahim Ismail Hundosa had been tortured and her head shaved while she was held captive, the reports said.
"Hundosa was found in a remote area of the capital, news reports said. Her family said that she had been subjected to 'physical torture and beating with whips' and that she had been told her head was shaved because 'it looked like the hair of Arabs while she belonged to the slaves in Darfur,' according to the pro-democracy group Grifina (We Are Fed Up). The journalist is now recovering at home with her family. . . . "
- "Univision and ABC News are looking to launch their Miami-based network by July 1, although that could be delayed until later in 2013, a company executive said," David Goetzl reported Friday for MediaPost. "Univision has invested $11 million so far as the English-language news and lifestyle channel targeting Hispanics remains in the prep stage."
- In August, this column reported that Kevin Weston, a new media entrepreneur in Oakland, Calif., who was about to start a journalism fellowship at Stanford University, was diagnosed with acute leukemia and was "in a real fight for his life." Weston now awaits a bone marrow transplant, he told "The People’s Minister of Information JR" of the San Francisco Bay View on Saturday. The interviewer announced, "on Monday, Nov. 26, at Yoshi's in Oakland, we will be honoring Kevin and a number of other Black media-makers who represent for the Black community in Northern California."
- ESPN sportscaster Stuart Scott gave $25,000 to President Obama's joint fundraising committee in September, Dave Levinthal and Tarini Parti reported Saturday for Politico. "KTLA-TV news producer Lisa Cox is listed among the president's September contributors because she bought campaign memorabilia from BarackObama.com. Cox also serves as secretary of the National Association of Black Journalists and says she gave away the items as gifts 'given the historic significance of Obama's presidency and his potential reelection.' . . ."
- Wesley Morris, Pulitzer Prize-winning film critic of the Boston Globe; the Rev. Al Sharpton; radio DJ Tom Joyner; Dick Parsons, former chair of Time Warner; and Associated Press entertainment writer Nekesa Mumbi Moody were among the 2012 EBONY Power 100 Honorees honored Saturday at New York's Lincoln Center.
- Discussing his reading habits, actor Denzel Washington told Stephen Galloway of the Hollywood Reporter that "he carefully follows the news, watching the evening broadcasts as well as CNN, perusing The New York Times daily ('That's where most of my news comes from') and even dipping into The New York Post, 'if I really want to feel sleazy,' " Galloway reported.
- Tony Harris who in December 2010 left CNN, where he was an Atlanta-based daytime anchor on "CNN Newsroom," took a personal look at his Baltimore hometown for his current employer, Al Jazeera, based in Doha, Qatar. "School and criminal justice systems biased against black boys; all echoes of my childhood. But I managed to avoid the trap of Baltimore's cycle of poverty and violence," Harris says. "But now I was going back to my hometown to get to the bottom of what I considered the new civil rights fight in America — educating black boys."
- "Journalism School students, faculty, and administrators will serve on the committee searching for the school's next dean, University President Lee Bollinger announced Wednesday," Jeremy Budd wrote for Columbia University's Columbia Spectator. "Earlier this month, Nicholas Lemann, who has been dean since 2003, announced his decision to step down from his position at the end of the academic year." Bollinger will chair the committee, which includes university trustee A'Lelia Bundles, author and a former Washington, D.C, deputy bureau chief of ABC News; Sree Sreenivasan, chief digital officer; journalism school professors Howard French, LynNell Hancock and Mirta Ojito; Duy Linh Tu, head of the digital media program; and Betsy West, professor.
- In Guinea-Bissau, "Reporters Without Borders is pleased to learn that the government has reversed its decision to expel Radio-Télévision Portugaise bureau chief Fernando Gomes and has promised RTP to guarantee his safety in the face of all the threats that have been made against him by soldiers," the press freedom organization said on Monday. "The media freedom organization hopes that this decision will also mark the end of the harassment to which all the media have been subjected in Guinea-Bissau."
Richard Prince's Journal-isms originates from Washington and is published Monday, Wednesday and Friday. It began in print before most of us knew what the Internet was, and it would like to be referred to as a "column." For newcomers: The words in blue (on most computers) are links leading to more information. The Web site BugMeNot.com provides passwords and user names to some registration-only news sites, but use may be illegal in some states. Any views expressed in the column are those of the person or organization quoted and not those of any other entity.
Send tips, comments and concerns to Richard Prince.
To be notified of new columns, contact firstname.lastname@example.org and tell us who you are.
Special thanks to The McCormick Foundation for its generous support of the Journal-isms column.
- Journo-diversity advocate turns attention to Ezra Klein project
(Erik Wemple, Washington Post, March 5, 2014)
- "Love, Peace and Soul!" And More
- Book Notes: Soothing the Senses, Shocking the Conscience
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2013
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2012
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2011
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2010
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2009
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2008
- Books to Ring In the New Year
- In-Your-Face Holiday Reads
- Fishbowl Interview With the Fresh Prince of D.C. (Oct. 26, 2012)
- NABJ to Honor Columnist Richard Prince With Ida B. Wells Award (Oct. 11, 2012)
- So What Do You Do, Richard Prince, Columnist for the Maynard Institute? (Richard Horgan, FishbowlLA Aug. 22, 2012)
- Who Am I? What's Race Got to Do With It?: Journalists Explore Identity
- Catching Up With Books for the Fall
- Richard Prince Helps Journalists Set High Bar (Jackie Jones, BlackAmericaWeb.com, 2011)
- 10 Ways to Turn Pages This Summer
- 7 for Serious Spring Reading
- 7 Candidates for the Journalist's Library
- 9 That Add Heft to the Bookshelf
- Five Minutes With Richard Prince (Newspaper Association of America, 2005)
- 'Journal-isms' That Engage and Inform Diverse Audiences (Q&A with Mallary Jean Tenore, Poynter Institute, 2008)
Work We <3 | FDP
Instead of spending all our time calling out journalism that doesn't work, we want to find work we like. We'd like to encourage our readers to submit links to content that is moving or challenging and that goes beyond the standard narrative either at the level of form or content. In other words, we want to see journalism that works.
We're particularly interested in work at the nexus of the following categories:
- Please include a comment explaining why the content you're sharing works.
- Comments can be as short or long as desired.
Find us on Facebook
Richard Prince Journal-isms Archive
Dori Maynard tweets on Diversity, Media & More
@JamilSmith The distorted #media depiction of African American men & boys has real life consequences, again. #mediadiversity #Tremaine