Pulling From Wikipedia: "Journalistic Laziness"
Friday, July 13, 2012
Lynn Hoppes, senior director/entertainment at ESPN, former newspaper sports editor and former president of Associated Press Sports Editors, has been scolded for "journalistic laziness" after the Deadspin website found that he had been "shall we say, over-reliant on Wikipedia as a research tool," as Deadspin put it.
ESPN spokesman Josh Krulewitz told Journal-isms Friday by email, "This obviously fell short of our editorial standards. Even though he used multiple legitimate news sources to gather background information, we should always recite even the most basic facts in an original voice, and source as warranted. That wasn't the case here. It was an example of journalistic laziness, and we've addressed it."
Hoppes' transgression was compounded because the items in Wikipedia, the source he used, are authored by citizens who are not always professional or unbiased.
Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales told Washington Post editors and reporters Tuesday, "As a journalist, you should double-source everything," according to Erik Wemple, writing for the Post. Wales said that journalists have "moved beyond the don't-use-Wikipedia" phase but said, "When we're doing our job well, we give you the references to dig deeper," according to Wemple.
Isaac Rauch wrote Tuesday for Deadspin, ". . . Whether it's verbatim cut-and-paste jobs or ethically ambiguous paraphrasing, most of Hoppes's tidbits — and tidbits are the primary medium in which Hoppes works — are pulled uncredited from his subject's Wikipedia page." Rauch then listed "the most glaring examples of this practice dating back to May 1."
Hoppes has been sports editor at the Orlando Sentinel and a radio host at Clear Channel Communications. In 2008, he became the second person of color to become president of the Associated Press Sports Editors. His LinkedIn profile lists him as "In charge of entertainment, video games, music, style/fashion and humor for ESPN.com. In charge of all serious commentary on ESPN.com."
Hoppes, who is Asian American, was last in Journal-isms in March, during the height of interest in New York Knicks phenom Jeremy Lin.
In a column for ESPN headlined, "Stop the Linsanity insanity," Hoppes wrote of Lin, "Please don't automatically assume that every Asian-American is rooting for him to become a star and help the Knicks make the playoffs.
"Provost John Coatsworth has appointed Sree Sreenivasan as Columbia's first Chief Digital Officer," Columbia University announced on Thursday. "A noted expert in new media and digital technology, he most recently was dean of student affairs at Columbia's School of Journalism, where he helped establish the school as an early leader in digital media."
Journalism School Dean Nick Lemann named Ernest R. Sotomayor, who was Long Island editor of Newsday.com when he was president of Unity: Journalists of Color Inc., to succeed Sreenivasan as the new dean of student affairs. Sotomayor was assistant dean for career services and continuing education programs.
In his announcement, Coatsworth said, "I am confident that Sree's experience in academic administration and his widely respected expertise in new media technology make him uniquely well suited for this challenge. Our goal is to ensure that we deploy new tools and technologies in interactive and distance learning to ensure the richest and most dynamic educational environment possible for Columbia’s students, as well as learners outside the University."
The news release continued, ". . . He has been named to several lists of digital- and social-media professors to follow; AdAge's 25 media people to follow on Twitter; and Newsweek's list of the 20 most influential South Asians in America. He will remain a member of the Journalism School faculty." Sreenivasan is a founder of the South Asian Journalists Association, which is meeting in Washington, D.C., on Saturday for its annual gala.
"As much as any single person, he has been the keeper of the heart and soul of the Journalism School," Lemann wrote of Sreenivasan, known to many simply as "Sree."
"In particular, he has been essential, beginning with his first days here, in bringing together the school and the digital revolution. He has been a superb evangelist for both causes, and has helped establish the school's international reputation for leadership in digital journalism."
|Video blogger Jay Smooth, right, focuses on Mitt Romney's NAACP speech in discussing "Mitt Romney’s Blackest Week Ever." (Video)|
Were the headlines about the boos for Mitt Romney at the NAACP convention this week overblown? Or did they capture the spirit of the NAACP delegates' reaction to the putative GOP presidential nominee, even if the boos were balanced by a standing ovation?
". . . If you read a headline or watched the news, most likely you're aware that Romney was booed for saying that he would repeal Obamacare," right-of-center columnist Kathleen Parker wrote Friday in the Washington Post. "What you may not know is that Romney also left the stage to a standing ovation.
"Suppose you were an editor, which headline would you prefer:
" 'NAACP boos Romney during speech about Obamacare'
" 'NAACP convention gives Romney a standing O'
Commentators of color, however, found much to fault in the Romney speech, with some suggesting that highlighting the boos was just fine with the candidate.
"Despite accusations to the contrary, Mitt Romney does get it," Mary C. Curtis wrote for the "She the People" section of the Washington Post website. "No one can go in front of the NAACP and talk of 'Obamacare,' a derisive term meant to provoke, and completely ignore the group's well-publicized concerns over voter-ID laws without getting it.
". . . In Montana, he reported in detail on how he meted out a dose of tough medicine the NAACP needed. 'Your friends who like "Obamacare," you remind them of this, if they want more stuff from government, tell them to go vote for the other guy — more free stuff.' He lumped together the business owners, ministers and middle-class folks who make up the membership of a venerable civil-rights group into just another bunch of freeloaders — and his base loved it.
"The members of the NAACP weren't individuals whose vote he courted. They were props. No mention of the applause he received at the beginning, end and during pieces of his speech the crowd liked. You can bet it's only 'the boos' you will see in fundraising pitches to the hard-core, evidence of stereotypes that didn't need any reinforcement."
- Lauren Victoria Burke, politic365.com: Obama: 1st Dem Nominee in 36 Years to No-Show NAACP in an Election Year
- Jonathan Capehart, Washington Post: Romney's hollow NAACP speech
- Michael Cottman, blackamericaweb.com: Romney to Blacks: Want Free Stuff? Vote for Obama
- Amy Davidson, New Yorker: Six Lessons from the Misreporting of the Health-Care Decision
- Wayne Dawkins, politicsincolor.com: Candidate Romney, Obamacare and unconscious bias
- Charles Ellison, politic365.com: Mitt Romney: Racial Folk Hero
- Rick Horowitz, YouTube.com: Like Obama Was Never There. (Video)
- Rick Horowitz, YouTube.com: Romney v. Romney (Video)
- Terry Krepel, Media Matters for America: Fox Airs Nearly All Of Romney Speech To NAACP — But Only A Minute And A Half Of Biden's
- David Lauter, Los Angeles Times: Race drives the presidential horserace
- Dr. Wilmer Leon, politic365.com: NAACP: Romney Played to Base, Did Obama Fear Being "Too Black?"
- Tony Norman, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: Romney's black support is easy to miss
- Clarence Page, Chicago Tribune: Mitt Romney's hidden NAACP audience
- Pew Research Center for the People & the Press: Obama Holds Lead; Romney Trails on Most Issues
- Touré, Time: Romney Plays The Race Card
- Michael Warren, Weekly Standard: Obama: My Biggest Mistake Was Not 'Telling a Story' (Updated)
Leaders of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists rejected requests to add questionable practices by its elections committee to the agenda of a "virtual town hall" scheduled Tuesday on the association's finances.
In a Facebook exchange Friday, member Daniel Morales asked, "Any chance we can discuss the elections and the irregularities by the elections committee as well? Both issues are very important at the moment. The abuse and scrutiny of non-halftime slate candidates is blatant," he said in a reference to the HalftimeInNABJ slate headed by Russell Contreras, "and could be a legal liability down the road if the professional careers of these candidates is adversely affected by the questionable actions of Michele Salcedo's chosen [elections] board."
Contreras, NAHJ vice president/print and chief financial officer, responded, "No. We will discuss finances only. This is the first time in years finances released before convention, first time there is financial virtual town hall, and first time we've had a surplus in years. Board voted on election chair and we will not get involved. The candidates on HalftimeInNAHJ were also vetted, had their respective HR departments contacted and provided all the requirements."
Salcedo, NAHJ president, replied, "All candidates have been asked to provide the same information and have been vetted in the same way. The requirements are published in the Elections Guidelines."
As reported on Wednesday, presidential candidate Hugo Balta, who is running against Contreras, said in an email that a member of the elections committee, failing to reach him immediately, called the human resources department of ESPN, his employer, "and asked if I was still w ESPN bc it was her understanding that I had accepted another job . . . . It was an unpleasant experience for me to say the least. I couldn't imagine how this false information could have happened!?"
Last week, supporters of television reporter Sal Morales of NAHJ's South Florida chapter said the NAHJ elections committee discouraged him from running for the general at-large seat, leaving only a HalftimeInNAHJ candidate in the contest.
Then Mekahlo Medina, a tech/social reporter at KNBC-TV in Los Angeles and non-slate candidate for vice president/broadcast, wrote that "I [received] a call from an election committee member WARNING me that my boss was 'unsure' if my organization would support my run. The problem here, my boss was on vacation and NEVER talked to her!"
Salcedo did not respond to a message seeking further comment, and Contreras would not comment on the record.
Contreras, a reporter for the Associated Press, said on Facebook, "The election committee can call my employer any time. They love me. Committee can also call my former employers, my wife, my Kindergarten teacher, my high school principal, my priest, my dog, my former students, my tejano godparents. Transparency is a good thing. Support it fully."
The "virtual town hall" follows questions that some NAHJ members have raised since March, when Salcedo announced that "according to our final financial numbers, NAHJ finished 2011 with revenues of more than $111,000 over expenses." The association projected a $240,000 deficit for 2010, then implemented severe cutbacks in 2011 to produce a surplus, it said. The "town hall" is scheduled from 7 to 9 p.m.
"Crystal Lumpkins, an assistant professor of journalism at the University of Kansas, has completed a study of coverage of women's health issues in popular women's magazines," the Journal of Blacks in Higher Education reported last week.
"Professor Lumpkins surveyed the editorial content of four popular magazines: Ms., Redbook, Good Housekeeping, and Essence. She found that these magazines ignored, for the most part, health issues of particular concern to African American women. Essence is largely targeted at African American women.
"Professor Lumpkins stated, 'The health stories that were most reported were on reproductive and sexual health. Diabetes, heart disease, HIV/AIDS, all of these major health issues in the African American community were not addressed.' "
Meanwhile, figures from the Publishers Information Bureau for April to June showed that, in general, magazines targeting Latinos and the venerable Ebony magazine continued to defy an advertising slump in the consumer magazine industry.
Ebony rose 49.7 percent in advertising dollars over the same period last year, and increased 44.5 percent in advertising pages. Ser Padres, a Spanish-language publication produced by Meredith Corp., rose 41.0 percent in advertising dollars and 10.7 percent in advertising pages. Its sister publication, Siempre Mujer, grew 18.7 percent in advertising dollars and 2.1 percent in ad pages. People en Español rose 13.4 percent in ad dollars and 6.8 percent in ad pages.
Showing declines were Black Enterprise, down 6.6 percent in ad dollars and 7.0 percent in ad pages; Essence, down 19.3 percent in ad dollars and 24.1 percent in ad pages; Jet, down 9.7 percent in ad dollars and 14.2 percent in pages; and Latina, down 4.9 percent in ad dollars and 6.3 percent in ad pages.
In April, Stephen Barr, Johnson Publishing Co. senior vice president/group publishing, attributed increases at Ebony to new advertisers.
Enedina Vega, vice president and publisher of Meredith Hispanic Ventures, attributed the increases at her publications to "the growing awareness among advertisers about the importance of the Hispanic market."
- Bill Mickey, Folio:: Magazine Closures Drop Significantly in First Half 2012
- Erik Sass, mediapost.com: Magazine Ad Pages Take Another Hit
- Joshunda Sanders, Maynard Institute for Journalism Education: Mainstream Media Tend to Ignore Blacks' Mental Health Problems
"When Marco Rubio sat down recently for an interview with Univision's Jorge Ramos, the spirited exchange made for great television. It also made Rubio look sympathetic, and Ramos unprofessional," Ruben Navarrette Jr. wrote this week in his syndicated column.
". . . That a class of people who shouldn't even be in this country in the first place, and don't have a legal right to remain here, have demands at all is one of the things wrong with the immigration debate.
". . . None of this seemed to get through to the Mexican-born Ramos, who really wanted to know why Rubio isn't more outspoken in defense of illegal immigrants. For instance, the journalist asked, how could it be that Rubio doesn't support 'legalization of the undocumented'? Rubio tried to interject that, in fact, he does support legalization for some illegal immigrants under certain circumstances. He just thinks that the issue is more complicated than proponents of comprehensive immigration reform are willing to admit.
"As Rubio tried to make his points, Ramos repeatedly cut him off so the anchor could make his. This wasn't an interview as much as an interrogation. Time and again, Ramos made clear that he expected better from the son of Cuban immigrants. . . ."
- Emil Guillermo, Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund: The war in Afghanistan, boot camp, and the Dream Act
- Prerna Lal, New America Media: It's More Complicated Than "Legal vs. Illegal": An Open Letter to Ruben Navarrette
"A crowd of prominent Atlantans flocked to the Fox Theatre Wednesday night to salute veteran news anchor Monica Pearson as she prepares to sign off for good," Jennifer Brett reported Thursday for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
"Oprah Winfrey made a surprise appearance by video to wish Pearson well.
" 'Monica, hey! I hear you are retiring,' Winfrey said during the video clip. 'I am really so very proud of you. I bow to you. Congratulations.'
"Nancy O’Dell from 'Entertainment Tonight' also appeared by video clip.
" 'We want to join your friends in Atlanta in wishing you the very best,' she said.
". . . The black-tie event was emceed by 'Good Morning America' co-host Robin Roberts, whose participation also was a surprise. . . ."
Meanwhile, Brett continued, Marietta Mayor Steve 'Thunder' Tumlin honored Condace Pressley, program director at WSB radio, and proclaimed July 11 "Condace Pressley Day" in the city because of her contributions to Marietta and to Georgia.
The Atlanta Association of Black Journalists plans to present Pressley the Pioneer Award July 29 at its 30th annual Pioneer Black Journalist Awards. Pressley is a past president of the National Association of Black Journalists.
"An Ethiopian court today handed down heavy prison sentences to six journalists convicted on vague terrorism charges, local journalists and news reports said," the Committee to Protect Journalists reported on Friday. "Award-winning blogger Eskinder Nega got an 18-year term; the others live in exile and were sentenced in absentia."
International press-freedom organizations denounced the sentences.
CPJ continued, " 'The court has given due considerations to the charges and the sentences are appropriate,' presiding Judge Endeshaw Adane told a packed courtroom at the Lideta Federal High Court in the capital, Addis Ababa, as he issued sentences for 24 defendants, including the journalists, convicted of involvement in a vague terror plot, according to wire reports.
"The judge accused veteran journalist Eskinder of participating in a terrorist organization, planning a terrorist act, and 'working with the Ginbot 7 organization,' a U.S.-based opposition group that the Ethiopian government formally designated a terrorist entity in 2011. The judge also accused Eskinder of wanting to incite anti-government protests in Ethiopia with online articles discussing the Arab Spring. Authorities have detained Eskinder at least eight times during Meles Zenawi's two decades as prime minister, according to CPJ research.
"Exiled journalists Mesfin Negash and Abiye Teklemariam received eight years each based on accusations of making information about Ginbot 7 available to Ethiopians through their news website, Addis Neger Online.
"Abebe Gellaw of the U.S.-based Addis Voice and Abebe Belew of U.S.-based Internet radio station Addis Dimts were each sentenced in absentia to 15 years, and Fasil Yenealem got a life sentence, based on their activities with pro-opposition exiled broadcaster Ethiopian Satellite Television (ESAT), which government prosecutors described in court documents as 'the voice of the terrorist organization Ginbot 7.'
"All of the journalists have professed their innocence, according to news reports."
- Saskia Houttuin, Radio Netherlands Worldwide: Ethiopia: Court Sentences Exiled Journalist in Holland to Life
- J. David Goodman, New York Times: Ethiopia: Dissident Journalist Sentenced
- Naomi Hunt, International Press Institute: Eskinder Nega Sentenced to 18 Years in Prison
- "Willis Edwards, longtime president of the Beverly Hills/Hollywood branch of the NAACP and key to launching the NAACP Image Awards on national television, died Friday in Mission Hills, California, according to a spokeswoman for Providence Holy Cross Medical Center," CNN reported. "Edwards, born in Texas and raised in Palm Springs, California, was 66. . . . He was never ashamed of his HIV-positive status and proudly proclaimed, 'I fought AIDS to a standstill,' said CNN assignment editor Greg Morrison." Los Angeles Sentinel tribute.
- "Americans' confidence in television news is at a new low by one percentage point, with 21% of adults expressing a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in it," Lymari Morales reported Tuesday for the Gallup organization. However, nonwhites expressed more confidence in television news than whites, according to figures provided to Journal-isms. Fourteen percent of whites expressed a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in television news, but 36 percent of nonwhites did. Respondents included 802 whites and 181 nonwhites.
- Atlanta is being highlighted in a month-long series by journalist Gil Robertson IV on HuffPost BlackVoices, Robinson said in a news release. "So far, the project has included 'Real Housewives of Atlanta' star Cynthia Bailey on what it's like living in Atlanta; actress Terri Vaughn on her favorite hotspots in Buckhead; and actress Jasmine Guy on the places she frequented growing up in southwest Atlanta," he said. Robertson also heads the African-American Film Critics Association.
- Bruce A. Dixon, managing editor of Black Agenda Report, delivered a harsh verdict on the black press and on the National Association of Black Journalists Wednesday under the headline, "The Black Press Is Dead. Get Over It." " . . . Black journalists are no longer advocates for the interests of African Americans," Dixon wrote. "Their blackness doesn't call them to protect the interests of ordinary black families and communities, who are suffering from grossly disproportionate unemployment and poverty, from over-policing, the forty year war on drugs and mass incarceration. Their blackness is only relevant as it reinforces their claim to specialness, namely the crumbs of affirmative action in hiring, promotion, and in rare cases the ability to own print or broadcast outlets." Dixon accuses NABJ of "distance" from black New Orleans in an education panel, but NABJ held a town hall meeting on the education issue at Dillard University.
- "On Fox News Channel's 'Fox & Friends' this morning, Geraldo Rivera once again brought up his comments regarding Trayvon Martin and 'hoodies,' " Alex Weprin reported for TVNewser. "Back in March, Rivera criticized parents who let their children go out wearing hooded sweatshirts, adding 'I think the hoodie is as much responsible for Trayvon Martin's death as George Zimmerman was.' He would apologize for the comment a few days later. This morning, Rivera returned to the topic, saying 'I was right about the hoodie wasn't I.'"
- "The radio station at historically Black Hampton University in Virginia has reached an agreement with Clear Channel Communications to make the station available worldwide over the Internet via iHeart Radio," the Journal of Blacks in Higher Education reported. "The station first went on the air in 1941."
- "The 'Fast & Furious' scandal has been a staple of right-wing media, where it is either evidence of a White House dodging accountability (a legitimate argument) or a plot to create chaos in order to pass more stringent gun laws (a bizarre and nonsensical conspiracy theory)," Peter Hart wrote Wednesday for Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting. "But a recent Fortune investigation (6/27/12) showed that the central claim at the heart of the scandal is flawed. Was there an ATF program to 'walk' guns into Mexico in order to catch drug lords on the other side of the border? No." Hart also faulted the reporting of ABC News' Pierre Thomas, recently named Journalist of the Year by the National Association of Black Journalists. Thomas told Journal-isms he would have no comment.
- "Two grenade attacks against its offices in the last two months was too much for Mexican newspaper, El Manaña," the Associated Press reported. "The local newspaper of northern Mexico border city Nuevo Laredo has announced that it will no longer cover acts of violence and criminal disputes in fear of continued retaliation by Cartels."
Richard Prince's Journal-isms originates from Washington and is published Monday, Wednesday and Friday. It began in print before most of us knew what the Internet was, and it would like to be referred to as a "column." For newcomers: The words in blue (on most computers) are links leading to more information. The Web site BugMeNot.com provides passwords and user names to some registration-only news sites. Any views expressed in the column are those of the person or organization quoted and not those of any other entity.
Send tips, comments and concerns to Richard Prince.
To be notified of new columns, contact email@example.com and tell us who you are.
- Books to Ring In the New Year
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2012
- In-Your-Face Holiday Reads
- Fishbowl Interview With the Fresh Prince of D.C. (Oct. 26, 2012)
- NABJ to Honor Columnist Richard Prince With Ida B. Wells Award (Oct. 11, 2012)
- So What Do You Do, Richard Prince, Columnist for the Maynard Institute? (Richard Horgan, FishbowlLA Aug. 22, 2012)
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2011
- Who Am I? What's Race Got to Do With It?: Journalists Explore Identity
- Catching Up With Books for the Fall
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2010
- Richard Prince Helps Journalists Set High Bar (Jackie Jones, BlackAmericaWeb.com, 2011)
- 10 Ways to Turn Pages This Summer
- 7 for Serious Spring Reading
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2009
- Diversity's Greatest Hits, 2008
- 7 Candidates for the Journalist's Library
- 9 That Add Heft to the Bookshelf
- Five Minutes With Richard Prince (Newspaper Association of America, 2005)
- 'Journal-isms' That Engage and Inform Diverse Audiences (Q&A with Mallary Jean Tenore, Poynter Institute, 2008)
Sign up for our Newsletter and get job tips
and the latest on diversity in the media
and the latest on diversity in the media
Find us on Facebook
Richard Prince Journal-isms Archive
Dori Maynard tweets on Diversity, Media & More
@brokeymcpoverty You can probably end that sentence at Maury.
Black man is hero. News media, nation seem mystified. It flies in the face of usual distorted media depiction #Ramsey http://t.co/RerQL9WEGG
@SherriEShepherd Childless by choice & always happy 2 help those w/kids before going to my quiet house Thx for keeping the human race going!